Petition Status


Current Goal
: 14500 People by June 1, 2012

Support To-Date: 14247 People (January 15th)

Stop the Mining: Sign Our Petition


Coloradoans Against Resource Destruction volunteers are very active.  See the Events menu for a list of upcoming events that we are either sponsoring or attending.  Contact us if you want to help us stop uranium mining in northern Colorado.  
Will uranium sites be adequately restored? Print

by Robert John Pennyfather

Guest Commentary
Greeley Tribune
August 15, 2007


A Canadian Company, Powertech Uranium Corp., has acquired rights to mine uranium on 5,760 acres close to the Weld-Larimer border near Nunn. The uranium price has increased dramatically in recent years, so profits of more than $100 per pound are now achievable, giving Powertech about $1 billion total profit. Consequently, Powertech is extremely anxious to capitalize on its mineral rights and is in the process of applying for the necessary permits.

Powertech proposes to extract uranium oxide using "in-situ recovery" by drilling numerous holes 250-600 feet down and inserting a caustic liquid that dissolves uranium oxide and also other heavy metals. The solution is pumped to the surface for processing, then the "cleansed" liquid is cycled round again.

The geologists' "Report on the Centennial Project, Weld County, Colorado" prepared for Powertech on March 28, glosses over the potential environmental impacts for both in-situ recovery and surface mining. However, recent history shows the mining industry has extremely unreliable environmental practices. Review of existing and previous in-situ recovery sites show numerous leakage events, often of tens of thousands of gallons of toxic liquids. This June, Smith Ranch in Wyoming had a 198,500-gallon spill containing 8ppm (parts per million) uranium two days after spilling 840 gallons containing 41.2ppm uranium.

The in-situ recovery process raises a number of major concerns, the chief of which is water quality. The Denver Basin groundwater aquifer covers 7,000 square miles from Weld County to Colorado Springs and from the Front Range to Limon. Within the Denver Basin there are four aquifers on top of each other, one of which, the Laramie-Fox Hills aquifer, will be used for the in-situ recovery mining.

As geologic and hydrogeologic systems are highly complex, no guarantee can ever be given that the caustic liquid with dissolved uranium and other heavy metals will not leak into the Laramie-Fox Hills aquifer and then into the other aquifers, poisoning the groundwater upon which hundreds of thousands of people, agriculture and industry depend. Additionally, leakage from surface equipment, pipes and containment ponds can result in contamination of the groundwater.

At the end of mining operations it is extremely questionable whether groundwater and the site itself can be returned to pre-mining conditions. At the Bruni in-situ recovery mine in Texas there were significant issues. During operation it had continual problems with surface spills and underground excursions contaminating soil and groundwater. Final cleanup efforts were ineffective, and the company requested the lowering of restoration standards to allow higher residual contaminants in the groundwater. After several years of restoration, the company still had significant problems meeting those reduced standards.

Companies are reluctant to invest the money to adequately restore sites as there is no return on investment for cleaning up contamination. Where authorities have required bonds to cover costs, they have often been totally inadequate and the costs of cleanup were borne by the taxpayer after the company vacated the site. The clean-up costs of the Canadian-owned Summitville Mine in Colorado cost the taxpayer $147.5 million, not to mention the sterilizing of 18 miles of the Alamosa River with cyanide run-off.

Residents of northern Colorado need to be aware of this proposed in-situ recovery uranium mining and should make informed decisions about whether it is in their and their families' long-term interests and, if necessary, take appropriate action accordingly. A good starting point for more information is

Robert John Pennyfather is originally from England and is a retired Chartered Accountant (the British version of a certified public accountant). He has been a Greeley resident since 2004.


Bookmark with:        What are these?

Make Donation: